- Sep 11 Don Slaught, American catcher (California Angels, NY Yankees), born in Long Beach, California
Wilfred Benítez (65 years old)
Sep 12 Puerto Rican boxer (youngest world champion at 17 years, 176 days [WBA Light Welterweight]), born in New York City
- Sep 16 Neville Southall, Welsh soccer goalkeeper (92 caps; Everton 578 games), born in Llandudno, Wales
Orel Hershiser (65 years old)
Sep 16 American baseball pitcher (LA Dodgers, Cleveland Indians), born in Buffalo, New York
- Sep 17 Daniel Nunez, Cuban weightlifter (Olympic gold 1980)
- Sep 18 John Aldridge, Irish soccer striker (69 caps, Republic of Ireland; Newport County, Oxford United, Liverpool, Real Sociedad, Tranmere Rovers), born in Liverpool, England
- Sep 19 Azumah Nelson, Ghanaian professional boxer, born in Accra, Ghana
- Sep 20 Remigijus Valiulis, Lithuanian athlete (Olympic gold USSR 4×400m relay 1980), born in Šilutė, Klaipėda, Lithuania (d. 2023)
- Sep 21 Rick Mahorn, American NBA forward, 1980-99 (Washington Bullets, Detroit Pistons, and 3 other teams), born in Hartford, Connecticut
- Sep 22 El Hadji Dia Ba, Senegalese hurdler (Olympic silver 1988), born in Dakar, Senegal
- Sep 23 Larry Mize, American golfer (US Masters 1987), born in Augusta, Georgia
- Sep 23 Marvin Lewis, American football coach (DC Baltimore Ravens Super Bowl 2000; Cincinnati Bengals 2003-18), born in McDonald, Pennsylvania
- Sep 28 Angella Issajenko, Jamaica, 4X100m relayer (Olympic silver 1984)
About September 1958
How Old? 65 years old
Generation: Baby Boomer
Leap Year: No
Baseball Players
Basketball Stars
Boxers
Footballers
NFL Stars
Tennis Champions